Our selection process

Compare the evidence behind a listing. Our directory is a starting point for research, with source-linked facts and a limited sample of public review snapshots.

1. Discover companies and preserve sources

We collect Indianapolis-area provider candidates from public web research and review company websites, location pages and public business profiles. A company without a standalone website can be included when a public social business page supplies usable identity or contact information. Discovery is ongoing: these 44 listings are not an exhaustive local census.

Published services and coverage statements retain their source, observation date and scope. Search snippets alone do not establish publishable service facts. Brand-wide claims stay separate from local claims. A city claim does not establish availability at your address.

2. Match the business and the branch

Before using a review snapshot, we compare the business name and available phone, address, website and branch details against the directory record. We directly read nine Google Maps profiles on November 1, 2026; the remaining 35 listings have no collected review snapshot. Missing review data does not mean zero stars or poor service.

Irish Brothers’ snapshot belongs to its Franklin profile; its Indianapolis-area coverage comes from a separate company statement. Orkin’s snapshot belongs only to residential branch #572 at 3932 Pendleton Way. Because the directory listing covers multiple branches, that snapshot is displayed with its branch qualifier and excluded from every review-based directory sort and shortlist. We do not combine branches or borrow a brand’s ratings.

3. Order comparable profiles using rating and volume

The default directory places providers with fresh, matched review snapshots first, then companies without comparable data alphabetically. The score is:

(n × r + 100 × 4.5) ÷ (n + 100)

r is the observed Google Maps rating; n is the observed review count. The 4.5-star, 100-review prior is our editorial comparison choice, not an estimated local average or a Google rating. It reduces how much a tiny sample can move a company’s position.

A 5.0-star profile with one review scores 4.505; a 4.8-star profile with 1,605 reviews scores 4.782. The larger sample therefore appears first under this method even though its raw star rating is lower.

We sort by score descending, then review count descending, then company name, with a stable identifier to resolve identical names. Directory controls also offer highest raw rating, most reviews and A–Z. Raw-rating and review-count sorts use the same comparable-profile eligibility. Displayed stars and counts are the original observations, not the adjusted score. They summarize the whole matched profile, not a particular pest, city, job or treatment outcome.

4. Apply extra checks to service shortlists

The service shortlists require a reviewed profile plus saved, page-read local evidence that the company advertises the particular service. Directory city and pest pages summarize collected coverage and service claims; they do not apply the stricter shortlist research rules. A termite inspection alone does not qualify as termite treatment. Categories need at least three fresh, locally eligible profiles for a full shortlist. Wildlife research remains incomplete.

Read the detailed editorial methodology for the exact service evidence used. A shortlist is a limited comparison, not an award or an overall winner.

5. Keep dates and gaps visible

At build time we exclude future-dated snapshots, invalid star/count values, zero-review observations and snapshots older than 90 days from ordering. Existing dated snapshots can remain visible as historical observations with their limits. The November 1 snapshots are due for refresh January 30, 2027. The current static build is dated 2026-11-16; this is not a live review feed.

We have not independently checked these providers’ licenses, conducted mystery shopping or test calls, verified treatment outcomes, or completed exhaustive credential and qualification vetting. Owner confirmation and license status remain unverified. Contact companies for current scope, prices and availability, and consult applicable official credential records before hiring.

See Contact and listing updates to reach the directory.

ZIP search and advertising

ZIP searches use Census ZIP-area reference points to estimate distance between ZIP areas. Companies without a usable location appear after those with calculated distances. This order is approximate and does not confirm service at an address.

A Sponsored company appears first in the default directory, pest and city lists, and in ZIP searches when its location ZIP matches, as long as it meets the selected filters. Rating, review-count and A–Z sorts are not changed. On the map it has a featured pin that marks a general area, not its address. Witts Pest Control is the current sponsor. Review scores and review-based ordering follow the method above.

Explore the directory